In dictating to the brass cylinders examples of the remarkable deductive abilities of my friend Herbert Krane, I have always presented the narratives in a straightforward and factual nature. I never endeavor to sensationalize any of our exploits and I am sure the recordings will bear witness to the truth in this assertion. It is, however, difficult to entirely separate the sensational aspects from the criminal in this particular case. With a disclaimer given, I will now consult my notes and reveal to you an exceedingly peculiar set of circumstances which not only caused one life to end prematurely, but broke a young woman’s heart as well.

It was a scorching hot day in mid-July. Rain had not fallen in weeks, and the rainmakers had all been grounded thanks to the petrol shortage. Kater Street shimmered in the yellow sun. Krane lay sprawled upon a sofa. He had dispensed with any attempt at repairing our domestic assistant. There was a catch in the gears in her left elbow which caused that appendage to jerk spastically. We found it hard to enjoy our customary scotch and sodas when half the liquid had splashed out onto the serving tray during her approach. We’d taken to living rustically and pouring our own drinks until the necessary repairs could be made.

“The heat plays havoc with the fine-tuning of the gears,” Krane had groused. Instead he was examining a letter which he had received by special delivery earlier that morning. I busied myself with some minor correspondence at the desk in the corner.

“It has always seemed to me a most preposterous means of settling a dispute,” Krane announced, as if we had been conversing. I pushed my papers aside and turned to my friend.

“What is?” I asked.

“Dueling.” Krane sat up and held up the letter he’d been reading. “Have you had the opportunity to examine this morning’s paper, Grant?”

I had skimmed the paper, so I nodded in assent.

“Did you take particular note of the brief story on page three, two thirds of the way down the page in the far left column?”

“Good heavens, Krane; I hardly know,” I blurted. “What was the nature of the article?”

Krane arose and—sighing at my apparent thickheadedness—picked up the paper folded on the end table. He tossed it in my direction. “Perhaps another perusal would allow us to continue our conversation.”

I felt piqued by my friend’s chaffing attitude, but dismissed it as a product of the oppressive heat. I picked up the paper he had thrown to me, and read the item indicated. It was headed “Body Found in Park” and read:

The body of Denis Evans was found yesterday morning near Biggin Hill in Bromley. Authorities from Scotland Yard have revealed that the body, which was discovered by a groundskeeper, suffered a single gunshot wound to the head. Evans was pronounced dead at the scene. The authorities believe Evans may have been involved in a duel and are currently seeking leads. No further information is available at this time.

I waited for any updates to scroll across the bottom of the page but when none appeared, I set the paper aside and looked up expectantly at Krane.

“I received this paper letter via special delivery this morning,” he said, holding up the note he had recently been absorbed in.

“Let me deduce who it was written by,” I interjected. “I see cheap paper, and the hurried scrawls of an antique ink pen. Even from where I sit across the room I can tell that the letter’s author harbors feelings of both reverence and dare I say, desire for at least half of the present occupants of this address. Therefore, the letter must have come from a female admirer.”

Krane gazed at me steadily. I snickered at my own joke. His brows were furrowed in disapproval, but the corners of his mouth twitched slightly as if he were holding back a smile.

“The letter is from an Inspector Crittenden,” Krane revealed. “He has solicited my assistance in the case you have just read.”

“I see.”

“I plan to leave shortly to meet Inspector Crittenden at the scene of the crime,” my friend continued. “Would you care to accompany me?”

“It is such a hot day and I have to catch up on my own correspondence,” I began. Krane held up a hand.

“Don’t make me beg, Grant,” he chided me lightly. “You have proven the worth of your companionship on numerous similar occasions.”

I searched his face for some trace of mockery but found none. Finally I rose and followed Krane out the door.

A replica hansom cab was waiting for us as we exited Krane’s quarters and we immediately climbed aboard. Gears engaged, hidden clockwork relays turned and we jolted on our way. Steam issued from the mechanical horses’ nostrils. The journey was a predominantly silent one as we each dealt with the oppressive heat in our own way. I believe my past law enforcement service in Australia gave me a slight advantage. I sat fairly comfortably, mopping my brow only occasionally. Krane wilted beside me, his eyes closed.

At last we arrived at Biggin Hill. The weather was slightly cooler in this southern borough. I don’t know if it was the drop to a more favorable temperature or the impending examination of the scene that revived Krane, but he disembarked from the cab with newfound alacrity.

Krane and I descended a gentle slope of grass toward a gnarled and imposing oak. At the foot of the oak stood a stocky man I took to be Inspector Crittenden. He stepped forward as we approached.

“Herbert Krane? It is my pleasure to make your acquaintance.” The man made a small bow and held out his hand. “I am Inspector Crittenden of New Scotland Yard.”

Krane took the proffered hand and looked around distractedly. Crittenden then turned to me. “You must be Kendrick Grant,” he said, “A pleasure, sir.”

“Thank you,” I said and we shook hands. The inspector’s grip was viselike. I wondered if he’d undergone some internal mechanical enhancements.

“Where was the late Mr. Evans employed?” Krane asked.

“He clerked and apprenticed at a haberdashery,” Crittenden revealed. “An authentic haberdashery. We’ve already visited his employer. The fellow was shocked; couldn’t believe what has happened.”

Krane pursed his lips, “So he hadn’t worked there long enough to be a victim of the sickness.”

The inspector shook his head. “The owner exhibited a bit of mental instability, but I am certain it was more affectation on his part than anything. Haberdasher’s Lament takes time; one does not earn it overnight.”

“Of course,” Krane nodded. He turned and wandered toward a spot approximately two meters from the oak and crouched down. Crittenden hurried over to join him and I followed suit at a leisurely pace.

“I see you have already discerned where the body was found, Mr. Krane,” Crittenden said. “As I wrote in my letter, two pistols were found at the scene. One was still clutched in the victim’s hand, the other lay less than half a meter away.”

Krane scanned the ground in all directions. “Was the victim right or left-handed?”

“The pistol was gripped in his left hand, if that’s what you’re asking.”

“It’s not,” Krane replied matter-of-factly. “But it does lead to my next question: where did the bullet enter Evans’ skull?”

“The right eye socket, near the bridge of the nose.”

Krane had stood back up. “Were both weapons discharged?”

“Yes,” Crittenden responded promptly.

“Were both slugs recovered?”

“One was retrieved from inside the victim, of course. It successfully dispensed its vial of acid. We have not recovered the other slug however,” the inspector admitted. “We surmise the shot went wild and could be anywhere.” He made a sweeping gesture over the vast expanse of brown grass surrounding us.

“It would be prudent to locate the slug before any children discover it,” I interjected. “If the acid vial has not shattered, a further tragedy could yet unfold.”

Krane forgave me for stating the obvious by ignoring me. “Would you humor us by walking through the events as the authorities believe they unfolded?” Krane asked Crittenden.

“Certainly,” the brawny man agreed. “We believe that Evans and another man met here by prearrangement. One of them brought a wooden box that held the two pistols; probably Evans since the items were left behind when the killer fled.”

Crittenden paused, waiting for Krane to make a judgment on this statement. When my friend only gazed up at the sky, the inspector continued.

“We believe the men stood back to back as is customary in a duel and walked their twenty paces. Both men turned and fired. Evans’ bullet missed its mark while his assailant’s bullet flew true. Evans fell to the ground. His killer approached the body and, upon finding him dead, tossed away his pistol and fled the scene.”

Krane looked at me. “What do you make of it, Grant?”

“Sounds like a solid appraisal of the events,” I allowed.

“And yet only one sentence the Inspector uttered is true; at least in a literal sense,” my friend announced.

Crittenden gaped at Krane. His jaw hung open for so long that I had to resist the urge to reach out a hand and gently close it myself.

“B-b-but Mr. Krane, h-h-how…?” Inspector Crittenden finally stammered. He reminded me of a mechanical minstrel with a scratched song cylinder.

“You said ‘Evans fell to the ground’ and in that statement you are correct,” Krane said. He strode about halfway back to our waiting replica hansom and knelt. “See here.”

Inspector Crittenden knelt beside Krane while I stationed myself between them and looked over their shoulders. Krane dug with his fingers into the sun-baked ground. In moments he withdrew a misshapen chunk of lead. Tiny shards of glass protruded from the tip. The acid had been safely absorbed into the earth.

“The second slug,” my friend announced and held it out to Crittenden. The inspector took it in amazement, examined it briefly and then made it disappear into a pocket.

Krane stood and brushed loose brown grass from his knees. “I believe that Evans was taken by surprise and was shot pointblank. With that in mind, it was easy to deduce that when the fatal bullet struck him, his fingers clenched reflexively and he pulled the trigger while the gun was still pointed in the air.”

“But how the deuce did you know where the slug would have landed?” Crittenden sputtered. “Was it a mathematical formula of trajectory?”

“It could have been, but not this time,” Krane admitted mildly. “I simply felt the hole in the ground under my shoe as we approached you.”

“You just happened to step on the hole,” the inspector repeated incredulously.

“Sometimes luck factors in,” our companion said blandly. Crittenden and I exchanged dubious glances as Krane continued. “Now then, I believe I have solved the case but should like to examine the quarters of the deceased. There are a few particulars that I am still in the dark about.”

Inspector Crittenden grabbed Krane by the shoulders. “Good Heavens, man! You know where the shooter is, then?”

“Beyond your reach I’m afraid,” Krane said soberly. “Now then, may we visit Evans’ quarters?”

“Yes, of course,” Crittenden replied, “But—”

“In due time, Inspector,” Krane said as he turned and strode toward our gently rumbling hansom. “In due time.”

The drive to Lewisham from adjacent Bromley was considerably shorter than our first trip of the day. Krane had ordered our driver to follow Inspector Crittenden’s sleeker ethyl-powered conveyance and settled back in his seat. I looked at passing scenery and was left alone with my thoughts. It was only as we approached the former residence of the late Mr. Evans that Krane roused himself.

“Now then, Grant, we shall have a firsthand look at how a singular man like Denis Evans lived,” my companion said. His eyes glittered with hilarity over some secret joke that I confess I could not fathom. The building itself looked similar to the others in the area, and—except for the fact that Evans had perished in a duel—I could ascertain nothing remarkable about the man or his situation.

Krane and I disembarked and strode toward Inspector Crittenden, who was already standing at the foot of the building’s front steps. Inside, on the first floor, we found the dwelling of the building’s superintendent. The inspector rapped sharply on the door, which quickly swung open to reveal a wispy little man with disheveled white hair and a pince-nez clipped to the bridge of a surprisingly bold nose.

Inspector Crittenden introduced himself and the little superintendent responded in kind. His name, he told us, was Eustace Lyons.

“We would like to examine the residence of Denis Evans,” Crittenden said.

“Yes, of course,” Mr. Lyons acquiesced. “A terrible business. He’s in two-oh-four. Was, I should say. If you gentlemen will follow me…”

Lyons led the way to the moving stairs, followed by Crittenden and then Krane. I brought up the rear. The little man threw a lever. Hidden wheels turned and gears engaged. The ascent was a remarkably smooth one, which is not always the case in these poorer neighborhoods.

“How long had Mr. Evans been a tenant?” Krane asked the white-haired man, above the hum of machinery.

“I’d say two years, give or take a month,” Lyons responded.

“Did you know him well?”

“I knew him well enough to nod hello whenever I saw him,” the superintendent said. “He was a pleasant fellow most days, although he had his quiet moments as well.”

“Oh?”

“You know how young clerks sometimes are,” Lyons confided. “One day they seem like they’re on top of the world, the next it’s as if they’re carrying a large chip on their shoulder.”

“That’s the way it was with Evans then?” Crittenden asked.

“Yes, you never knew if he was running hot or cold. Always very courtly in his manners, though. He was a bit old-fashioned in that regard.” Lyons had stopped before the outer door of the apartment Evans had rented. He withdrew a gold key, inserted it into the lock and turned it. The outer door slid into the wall revealing the apartment’s vault door. The superintendent twisted the knob right, left and right as he consulted a series of numbers displayed on tiny squares of paper under the glass of a converted timepiece. The ingenuity of his invention convinced me the little landlord was also to thank for the perfect operation of the moving stairs. A hollow thud told us the apartment was now unlocked. Lyons pressed his palm against the door and made as if to enter but Krane stopped him with a hand on the shoulder.

“I should prefer to enter first,” my friend confided gravely.

The smaller man looked affronted and opened his mouth to reply but Krane spoke first. “For investigative purposes, of course; I have reason to believe the killer may have been on the premises recently.”

The superintendent jerked backward in such surprise that the pince-nez popped off his nose. Inspector Crittenden also cast a startled look in Krane’s direction. Lyons kept my attention. His pince-nez swung from its black ribbon like a man from a noose. This sobering image returned my thoughts immediately to the matter at hand.

Krane had already entered Evans’ former quarters. I could see his silhouette outlined in the window as he moved about the interior. Krane disappeared down a short hall, which presumably led to sleeping quarters and the bath. Moments later he returned to the door.

“It is just as I suspected,” Krane said blandly. My friend stood aside and we all entered. The young bachelor was by turns tidy and slovenly. Dirty clothing had been thrown helter-skelter across the floor in the sitting room, while in the bedroom all the clothing hung neatly pressed on hangers. Polished black shoes and dirty brown boots stood side by side in the tiny foyer. The bed was neatly made, yet the couch in the sitting room was in disarray. I thought this odd and after we had perused the rooms, I approached my friend.

“What do you make of it, Grant?” he asked me.

“It looks as if two people lived here,” I volunteered. The wispy little superintendent shook his head as if to argue, but Inspector Crittenden nodded, stroking his chin thoughtfully.

“On what do you base this assessment?” Krane inquired.

“The clothing and other household items,” I responded. “Some are put in their proper places while others are strewn about carelessly.”

“Did any of you gentlemen happen to notice the pictograph on that wall?” Krane asked with a long arm outstretched and his index finger pointing.

We all turned and moved in for closer examination. The framed pictograph showed a rather beautiful young woman turning and gazing precociously at the camera. Her dark hair hung in ringlets and she flashed a marvelous smile and blinked long eyelashes. She looked to me like a woman who could steal hearts on a whim. As we watched, the scene started over. I confess I nearly fell in love all over again as she turned her gaze upon the camera. After her third glance over her shoulder, I tore myself away and turned back to Krane.

“Am I correct in my assessment that this young lady could be considered quite attractive?” Krane asked us. We all nodded and chorused our assent.

“Did any of you look close enough to make out the inscription?” Krane pressed.

Lyons and I both turned back to the pictograph in surprise but Inspector Crittenden nodded. I removed the item from the wall and tilted it slightly for better viewing.

For Denis and Ralph with all my love, Charlotte. ” I read aloud.

“Good heavens,” Lyons exclaimed. “A proclamation of love directed at two men?”

“Perhaps it is just a friendly term of endearment,” I suggested. “They may all be old school chums.”

“Regardless, we now have a solid lead on a suspect,” Crittenden said.

I nodded my assent and passed the pictograph to the inspector.

“But I never saw anyone other than Evans enter or leave his quarters,” Lyons attested. “Who was this Ralph? How could he have been staying here without my knowledge?”

“Ralph could have been here with precious few knowing about it,” Krane declared. “I suspect Charlotte and Denis may have been the only two persons aware of Ralph’s presence.”

“Then we must make every effort to locate the woman in the pictograph,” Inspector Crittenden said, “Perhaps she knows the whereabouts of the mysterious Ralph. I believe he could very easily have been the second participant in the duel.”

“I agree with the inspector in that we must seek out this young lady, albeit with a different purpose in mind.” Krane said, then he turned to the inspector. “How soon can you have men making inquiries?”

“Within the hour,” Crittenden announced after a moment’s consideration. He had turned the pictograph over and was examining the back. “We can start with the shop where the pictograph was taken.”

“Capital! Let’s have some fresh air then,” Krane replied. He strode out of the room and disappeared in the direction of the moving stairs. Inspector Crittenden thanked Mr. Lyons for his assistance and we left the superintendent to lock up and hurried down after Krane.

Inspector Crittenden and I found him already seated in our hansom. The driver had kept the cab running and the mechanical horses had built up full heads of steam in a very literal sense. Krane spoke as we approached. “Fourteen blocks south, we passed a small but serviceable-looking eating establishment during our journey. Grant and I have breakfasted, but have not eaten since. I, for one, am famished and would make the supposition that my friend is as well.”

I nodded in the affirmative and Krane went on. “I wonder if you would be kind enough, Inspector, to notify us with any news on the whereabouts of the lovely Miss Charlotte?”

Inspector Crittenden nodded and Krane gave him the name of the restaurant where he intended us to dine. Crittenden returned to his own speedier conveyance and Krane signaled our driver. Once we were off, I engaged my friend in a bit of light banter on a few meaningless topics. I knew better than to press my companion about the current case. Krane would reveal all in due time.

Forty minutes later, we had just pushed back our plates from a exceedingly satisfying early dinner when a panting youth wearing the insignia of New Scotland Yard’s Junior Officer Program entered the establishment and looked around expectantly. My companion nodded when the newcomer looked our way and the youth hurried over.

“Mr. Herbert Krane?” he asked. My friend nodded. The young man removed his starred cap. “I sure am honored—”

“You needn’t be,” Krane assured him. Then he asked briskly, “You have a communiqué for us?”

“Yes, yes!” the young man said, as if just remembering. He pulled a small ink-stained cube from his front pocket and placed it carefully on the table. From his other pocket the lad produced a jar of liquid. He unscrewed the lid, revealing a brush attached to the underside of the metal cap. He quickly and carefully applied a fresh coat of ink to the cube and stepped back. Krane glanced at the cube and then held it up for me to read.

Misters Krane and Grant,

The photographer remembered her immediately. Miss Charlotte Bennett resides at 2----Altamont Terrace, also in Lewisham. Will meet you on site.

Inspector Crittenden

“I was looking forward to having a smoke after dinner,” Krane sighed resignedly as his long fingers tapped his cigar case. “But I suppose time is of essence.”

I knew Krane well enough to note the glimmer in his eye and realized that he was looking forward to an audience with the newly discovered Miss Bennett.

“Just smoke in the cab on the way,” I said and rose to pay the bill. The youth stepped in to retrieve his cube and I paid him a small tip as well.

Our driver was familiar with the Altamont Terrace address and indicated that it was nearby. Krane and I took our seats and in a matter of minutes our hansom rattled and hissed to a stop in front of the young woman’s residence.

We waited outside for Inspector Crittenden to arrive. Krane continued to smoke placidly while I watched the windows for any sign of movement. The skies had started to darken, but no lamps had been lit within Miss Bennett’s dwelling.

I pointed this out to Krane, saying, “Perhaps she is not at home.”

“She’s home,” my companion replied, but would say no more.

After another ten minutes, Crittenden arrived. “I made for New Scotland Yard and had to double back,” he explained apologetically.

The three of us found ourselves once again at a stranger’s door. Inspector Crittenden knocked and we waited. When no one immediately answered, Crittenden rapped harder. Finally a muffled voice came from the darkness within.

“Yes?”

“Miss Charlotte Bennett?” Crittenden inquired.

“Who’s calling?”

“Inspector Crittenden of New Scotland Yard. I’d like to ask you a few questions.”

The door opened a crack, revealing a bloodshot blue eye which otherwise would have been beautiful if not for the puffiness of recent tears. Her cheek was flushed and she appraised us all bleakly.

“What is it that you want, Inspector?” she asked after several moments of silence.

“We came to offer our condolences, my dear lady,” Krane surprised me by saying.

Miss Bennett met his gaze, still holding the door open only a crack. “And you are?”

“Herbert Krane. This is my friend Kendrick Grant,” he gestured toward me. Her eyes widened briefly in recognition, then narrowed.

“I see you already know my situation,” she said to Krane. “Have you come simply to satisfy your curiosity?”

“We do have some questions,” Inspector Crittenden began, but Krane cut him off.

“Our aim, Miss Bennett, is only to put this matter to rest and in so doing, preserve the honor of the man you cared so deeply for.”

Her eyes met his and after another pause, her resolve seemed to crumble and she opened the door wide to admit us into her home. It was small and old-fashioned, but appeared clean and comfortable. Miss Bennett lit a lamp on a small end table and sat down in a nearby chair. Krane perched in the chair opposite her while Inspector Crittenden stood nearby. I lingered near the door where I could more easily see the group.

“How long were you acquainted with Mr. Denis Evans, Miss Bennett?” Krane inquired.

“Over a year,” she replied. “Fifteen months to be more precise.”

“Very good,” Krane said and tented his fingers. “And how much time passed before you became aware of Ralph?”

Miss Bennett flushed slightly. “It was about four months. I’d noticed a change in Denis’ moods from time to time but it wasn’t until I’d actually been a guest inside his home that I realized his situation.”

“And yet you continued the friendship,” my friend observed.

“Of course,” Miss Bennett replied, raising her chin. “I had begun to care a great deal about Denis.”

“And Ralph?”

“Despite their differences, both Ralph and Denis treated me like complete gentlemen. In time, they both professed their love for me.”

Inspector Crittenden finally could stand it no more. “You are obviously aware, Miss Bennett, that Mr. Evans lost his life in a duel yesterday morning.”

Miss Bennett nodded and blinked away fresh tears.

“We believe the fellow you call Ralph is responsible for the deed,” Crittenden pressed. “We know this is very difficult for you, but he must be brought to justice.”

Miss Bennett shrugged her shoulders and gave the inspector a humorless smile. Crittenden pounded a fist into the palm of his other hand. “If you withhold information, you will be obstructing the law, Miss Bennett,” he warned.

She looked tiredly at Krane. “Do you wish to tell him or should I?”

I was taken aback when he reached out and took her hand. “Dear lady, you have been through so much.”

She lowered her head and bit her trembling bottom lip in an effort to stave off the sobs that now wracked her body. Krane looked up and addressed the inspector and myself. “Miss Bennett loved two men within the same body.”

Inspector Crittenden scowled, not understanding, but realization dawned upon me and I confess that I gasped aloud. The remarkable situation suddenly became clear and a feeling of sympathy rose within me for the girl.

“What the devil are you driving at?” Crittenden finally ejaculated.

“Denis Evans suffered from multiple personalities,” Krane explained. “Not quite the madness it was once believed to be, but still a curious medical condition. Grant may have more knowledge upon the subject than I.”

I stepped forward. “A contemporary of mine, Dr. Eugene Azam recently wrote a paper concerning a woman he called Felinda X,” I began. “Dr. Azam is a professor of surgery who has a great interest in hypnotism. While under his care, this Felinda X exhibited three different, distinct personalities. Even more surprising, each personality apparently had no knowledge of the others. Whenever one personality took control, the others experienced periods of amnesia.”

“Why that sounds preposterous!” Inspector Crittenden cried. “A child’s fairy tale!”

“Not at all,” Krane said with quiet authority. “I will explain more outside.” He turned to our hostess. “Miss Bennett, would you like us to summon someone to stay with you and attend to your needs during this difficult time?”

“My mother, Lady Frances Bennett, should be arriving by zeppelin tomorrow,” Miss Bennett replied, dabbing at her eyes with a limp handkerchief. “I sent for her this morning after I read the horrible news in the morning edition.”

“If that is the case, let us depart,” Krane instructed. “We have intruded upon Miss Bennett for too long.”

I glanced at the young lady who, even in her sorrow, looked exquisite. I offered my condolences and followed Krane, who had stood and was ushering the stunned inspector from the room.

Inspector Crittenden kept silent until we were beside our hansom replica, then he blurted, “This is really more than I can swallow, Mr. Krane. I hoped you might discover some overlooked clue, not put forth a sensationalized and ludicrous theory about the case!”

Krane only smiled thinly and raised both hands in a placating gesture. “Give me only a few moments, Inspector, and I will explain myself fully.”

Crittenden frowned but nodded.

“I suspected something out of the ordinary immediately upon examining the crime scene,” Krane began. “The earth was dry and the grass brown from the heat and lack of rain. The blades broke easily wherever we trod. You and your men stomped most of the grass between the road and the tree, but I was still able to distinguish Mr. Evans’ movements. I discerned right away where the unfortunate young man had initially paced under the oak tree, waiting for Ralph to arrive. I saw where Evans turned and counted off his paces, but I could find no corresponding disturbance in the grass of anyone walking in the opposite direction. The grass there was untouched. Moreover, based on the angle Evans took, his adversary—had there been one—could have taken only four or five paces before being obstructed by the large oak tree that stands there. When you described where the slug had entered the victim, I surmised briefly that the shooter was standing right next to the victim when he fired his pistol.”

Krane paused and glanced at the inspector, who was now nodding solemnly. I myself had no trouble visualizing the scene at the base of Biggin Hill as Krane described it, and I’m sure Inspector Crittenden was mentally doing the same. Evans’ last moments came to me with startling clarity.

“Evans turned to fire, only to find that his ‘opponent’ had decided against the gentlemanly approach,” Krane continued. “I realized that ‘Ralph’ had crept up on him, so to speak, and pulled the trigger from the only range possible.”

“Point blank.” Crittenden’s voice was little more than an awed whisper. He looked up at Krane. “Pray continue.”

“There’s not much more to tell about the act itself,” Krane replied. “The Ralph personality took umbrage to Denis and his interest in Miss Bennett. Although Denis himself may have been the dominant personality, Ralph may well have been the more passionate of the two. They decided on a duel, with the winner free to advance his relationship with Miss Bennett. You’ve seen the result.”

“But Krane,” I interjected. “In nearly all documented cases of split or multiple personalities, each personality experiences periods of amnesia, or blackouts, when another side is in control. How in heaven’s name did Denis learn of Ralph’s presence?”

“Sadly, Miss Bennett is to blame,” Krane revealed. “Matters came to a head when she inscribed her photograph to both personalities. Imagine adjoining rooms. By expressing her affection for both personalities, Miss Bennett threw open the door connecting the two rooms and the tenants got a good look at one another.”

“You mean to say…?” Crittenden began.

“Yes,” Krane replied somberly. “This young woman unconditionally loved and accepted Mr. Evans despite his peculiar condition, but she inadvertently brought about his death by acknowledging both personalities in her proclamation of love.”

Crittenden uttered a low oath. I felt my sympathies rising once again on behalf of Miss Bennett.

“So in the end, there is no one to be brought to justice,” the inspector concluded. “It was a victimless crime.”

“Not at all, Inspector,” Krane disagreed as he stepped up and settled into our cab. “There was no crime, but there is a victim.” He glanced meaningfully up at Miss Bennett’s window.

Crittenden stepped back and raised one hand in salutation as our driver threw a lever and the mechanical horses sprang forward. Krane slumped back against the seat.

“Dreadful business, that,” I volunteered. “But may I congratulate you on your remarkable deductions.”

“Thank you, Grant,” my companion replied flatly. I could see that familiar melancholy settling upon him. “My findings in this case have left me in a somber and introspective frame of mind. Pray, leave me to my thoughts until we have returned to Kater Street.”

I settled back and tried to relax, but the hum of the hansom’s wheels and the clatter of steel hooves on the cobblestones quickly disturbed my thoughts. The incessant buzzing of the gears and the squeals of steam ejecting from rubber nostrils reminded me of voices arguing heatedly with one another and the drive proved to be a long and uncomfortable one.

 

# # #

The Biggin Hill Duel by Adrian Ludens
originally published in the Spring 2012 print edition

 

 


Adrian Ludens is a radio announcer living in the Black Hills of South Dakota. Favorite and recent appearances include: Alfred Hitchcock’s Mystery Magazine, Morpheus Tales, Blood Lite 3: Aftertaste (edited by Kevin J. Anderson, Pocket Books), and numerous anthologies from Blood Bound Books, Pill Hill Press and others. Visit Adrian online at curioditiesadrianludens.blogspot.com

For more of Adrian's work,
visit his Big Pulp author page

 

This feature and more great
fiction & poetry are available in
Big Pulp Spring 2012:
The Biggin Hill Duel

Purchase books and subscriptions
in the Big Pulp book store!

 

 

Purchase books and subscriptions
in the Big Pulp book store!

 

Store ø Blog ø Authors ø Supporters ø Submissions ø About ø Exter Press ø Home
Art gallery ø Movies ø Fantasy ø Mystery ø Adventure ø Horror ø Science Fiction ø Romance

All fiction, poems and artwork © the authors. Big Pulp © 2012 Exter Press